I'd like to begin with an exercise, and I'll ask you to be gentle with yourself as you do it.
Think of the worst thing you have ever done. The one you hope no one ever finds out about. The memory that still makes your stomach drop at three in the morning.
Now imagine that the person sitting next to you knows only that. Not the years you showed up for your family. Not the times you were kind when no one was watching. Not the work you've done to become someone different. Just the worst moment, and nothing else.
Notice what comes up. Maybe it's shame, or a pull to explain yourself, or a heavy wish to be seen as more than that one thing. Hold onto that feeling for a moment, because for many of the people I work with, this is not an exercise that ends. It is daily life. It is what it means to be justice impacted, and to carry a scarlet letter long after the sentence has been served.
As a clinical psychologist operating in forensic settings, I spend my days with people who have been arrested, incarcerated, or caught up in the court system, with the families who love them, and with those who have been hurt by their actions. Let me say something first, because it matters: harm is real. The people who were hurt are real, and their pain deserves to be honored. Nothing here is meant to minimize that. Accountability matters, and I believe in it.
But being held accountable and being defined forever by your worst moment are two different things.
What the scarlet letter feels like. A sentence can end, but the label rarely does. It follows people onto job applications, apartment applications, and background checks. It shows up in a neighbor's changed expression, in the relative who quietly stops calling, in the assumption that a person is nothing more than their record. Many of my clients tell me the hardest part wasn't the time itself. It was the "after," where the punishment seems to have no end date and the door keeps closing.
What it does to a person's heart and mind. When the world sees someone only as their worst act, it becomes very hard for that person to see anything else. Shame takes root and hardens into identity: This is who I am. This is all I'll ever be. I see the toll clinically, in depression, anxiety, constant vigilance, isolation, and a deep loss of hope. And I often see people who badly want to change, but who are told by every closed door that change won't count. It is very hard to become a new person when no one will let you.
The story behind the story. Many of the people I sit with carry long histories of their own pain: abuse, neglect, violence, and loss that began years before the moment that landed them in the system. I share this not to excuse harm, because understanding is not the same as excusing. I share it because it reminds me that behind every case file is a human being with a childhood, a wound, and a story. When we meet that with care instead of only punishment, the results are often better for everyone, including those who were harmed.
What I've seen help. Safe housing and steady work. Treatment for trauma, mental health, and substance use. A mentor or community that sees the whole person. A family brave enough to hold two truths at once: What happened was wrong, and you are still worth believing in. I have watched people rebuild their lives, and it remains one of the most sacred parts of my work.
A few words, depending on where you're standing:
If you are justice impacted, what you did is something that happened. It is not the sum of you. You are allowed to grieve it, to take responsibility for it, and still to hope. Find people and places that see you fully, and be patient with yourself on the long road back. Counseling can help you confront and release the shame without letting it become your name.
If you love someone who is, your steadiness matters more than you know. Staying connected, where it is safe to do so, can be the thread that reminds them they are still part of a family and a community.
If you are an employer, landlord, teacher, or leader, consider what a fair chance could mean for someone. Second chances do not threaten safety. They help build it, because people with a way back in have something to lose and something to live for.
If you've never stood in those shoes, return to the exercise at the start. Remember how it felt to imagine being known only by your worst moment. Then offer someone else the grace you would hope for yourself.
None of us is only the worst thing we have ever done. Most of us are simply grateful that no one is keeping that list.
**If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out to a mental health professional. In the U.S., you can call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at any time.

